Forum Topic

Philippa, you really are a prejudiced individual.‘If you walk down a street instead of just getting into a car and whizzing off in your own little bubble you would appreciate this.  You are also more likely to see, greet and chat to neighbours.’  I walk everywhere locally, and see and hear a lot of what goes on. Keep your stupid cognitive bias for your own family, eh?You are incorrect to say council tax is only spent on social care. Yes, that’s a large proportion of it (and I think that central government should be funding that entirely), but areas such as waste collection, highways and other services are also funded from this tax. I’m sure you can find a link to help enlighten you.You missed the point about Bell’s council tax freeze. He chose not to make modest increases year on year to keep things running, preferring to blame the Coalition and the Tory governments. A handy thing to put in his taxpayer funded propaganda sheet Around Ealing. I said about the consequences of this at the time, and subsequently, and it means bigger increases now for everyone at a time when household budgets are further squeezed.You keep wittering on about garden waste. Most residents who could afford to were happy to pay the subscription. That’s changed this year because the rate increases and the service was reduced by a third, hardly value for money. Still, we get value for money with those increased allowances for councillors.Here’s a link showing what they pick up for making those open, honest and transparent decisions: https://www.ealing.gov.uk/download/downloads/id/2551/members_allowances_scheme.pdfIf you think we have sensible people running things then you must be deluded. The Council has its Broadway Living development arm, with a £400m loan (guaranteed by Ealing taxpayers). It’s supposed to deliver (allegedly) genuinely affordable homes across the borough. Since its inception in 2014 it has completed just 93.Yes, in a decade Broadway Living has built just 93 homes. And you wonder why there’s a housing crisis.The latest figures for the business don’t make pleasant reading either:Period Ended 31 Mar 2024For period 31 Mar ⟶ 31 Mar 2024Traded for 12 monthsCash in Bank£1.14MIncreased by £787K (+220%)Turnover£802KIncreased by £379K (+90%)EmployeesUnreportedSame as previous periodTotal Assets£31.45MIncreased by £1.95M (+7%)Total Liabilities-£37.7MIncreased by £7.68M (+26%)Net Assets-£6.25MDecreased by £5.73M (+1093%)Debt Ratio (%)120%Increased by 18.09% (+18%)If it wasn’t for the council pumping money in this business would have collapsed years ago.Think about that when your next increased council tax bill hits the doormat.

Simon Hayes ● 242d

Simon. You give the wrong impression about Council Tax.  Govt has been in control of that for years - reducing the grant Govt gave to Councils and then only allowing Councils to increase Council Tax by a small percentage and specifying what that could be used for - social care - which is greatly needed especially with an increasing elderly population.In an effort to reduce the size of State responsibility Govt employed Consultants to see where costs could be saved and it was one of these who recommended that garden waste which Councils don't or didn't have a statutory duty to collect could be charged for.  I argued against this then as I could see that this was likely to mean a reduction in green spaces as householders paved or concreted over them to save money.  Increased hard surfaces exacerbate heat and flooding whereas trees, shrubs and gardens contribute to everyone's wellbeing as well as allowing water to percolate the surface.  If you walk down a street instead of just getting into a car and whizzing off in your own little bubble you would appreciate this.  You are also more likely to see, greet and chat to neighbours.  This also meant that many of those who composted their garden waste to enrich their garden soil making it more porous and feed their garden plants and consequent butterflies and bees etc stopped and took advantage of what was initially a free collection.  (Garden waste was banned from black bag household waste collections.)  A good tradition lost with further consequences.

Philippa Bond ● 242d

Come off it Philippa. You are really pushing the boundaries of credibility now.The council has mechanisms to raise money, including council tax. Under Julian Bell the council chose to freeze council tax for several years, purely as a vote winning measure. Residents would have accepted a modest rise each year, and the continuation of services. That’s expected but can be budgeted for. Instead we got bleats about government cuts and a lot of virtue signalling.And what’s been the result? Massive increases in the last few years and another on the horizon. But at least our ‘hard working’ councillors are cashing in.Then add in the mayoral precept, which was an inflation busting 8.9 percent last year, and you can see why Londoners don’t really feel they get value for money. A lot of Khan money goes on wasteful gimmicks like cheap Friday fares for a few months (another election bribe) that cost £24m and was a total failure.But if you want to see how wisely our council spends our money have a look at the planning and development departments. They’ve messed up the proposed new builds at Deans Gardens and Southall Market, with the developers walking away due to financial problems. The council cabinet last week proposed to reacquire the sites to try to push on with the building work. It’s doing this through its Broadway Living entity. The cost so far of all this to Ealing taxpayers? £27.8m for Southall and £7.5m for Deans Gardens.This money will supposedly be recouped through sales on both sites, but it’s doubtful anywhere near these eye-watering sums will be realized. And the costs will be higher because this is just what’s needed to get work restarted. The council took out a £400m loan about four years ago, basically for property speculation as Bell and Mason fancied themselves as high flying developers after too many freebie trips to Cannes! Croydon council went bust because it follliwed a policy like this so the warning signs were there, and brightly lit too!If Ealing does go belly up the current council tax rates will seem like small change. Croydon residents had a whopping 15 percent hike last year. If councillors and officers were held personally accountable for reckless behaviour none of this would ever happen.Of course, none of this gets reported so residents are blissfully unaware of the risk others have exposed us to.

Simon Hayes ● 242d